Please, let this time be not different. Please let this recovery be the similar to all the previous recoveries.
I have just finished reading This time is different by Carmen M. Reinhart and Kenneth S. Rogoff. They bring together statistical data on all the world’s known debt and banking crises and look for patterns that precede them. Their title comes from people saying during each boom that there will not be another crisis because we now have knowledge and experience from previous crises and “this time will be different.”
Following each crisis there has been recovery in which the economy has grown to a new high. For the sake of all the people who are suffering from the current crisis it would be good if this time is not different and we could have a full normal recovery. It would be even better for the planet and our long-term well-being if we could adapt our economy so that people would not suffer from zero or negative economic growth.
One of the things which is different for this recovery is that the marginal cost of extracting energy, mineral and agriculture resources has increased. We have used up the most easily available of these resources and those that are left take a lot more work to extract. This is bound to limit the potential for further economic growth. We should beware of believing economic growth can continue forever.
I think there is an element of truth in the Elliott Wave Theory which applies to economics as well as the stock market. This theory says ups and downs run in series of fives and after the fifth the overall trend reverses. Within each up and down there are series within a series. I don’t know about the fives but I believe the economy is fractal in nature and that there can be major turning points. We should not rule out the possibility that we have passed a major turning point and that for some time to come we will have a series of downs and ups with each down going even lower.
As I read this book I wondered how the crises impacted people’s lives. How serious was the unemployment? How did people cope with unemployment? Who were the people who lost their savings from defaults or inflation and how did they cope? Did some of the one percent find themselves joining the poor?
In the current crisis, the headlines indicate young people are being hit hard and are the lost generation. Meanwhile the cruise ships are packed with older people planning their next cruise.
It could be that during an economic boom we have a psychological need for economists to be telling us the boom will not end in a crisis. Then we can work hard to prepare for retirement and to provide short-term profits for people in the financial industry. We want to hide from ourselves the possibility we will lose the benefits of our hard work to defaults, haircuts or inflation.
As I was reading about all the financial crises I was saying “why oh why oh why would anyone want to put effort into the financial industry when there is such a high probability we will lose a lot of our savings?” But then I have never been much for ambition.
Filed under: Economics | Tagged: banks, credit crisis, debt, debt crisis, economic growth, economic recovery, Economics, Elliott wave theory, financial crisis, Fractals, negative economic growth, This time is different | Leave a comment »