“Can someone explain to me why it’s so hard for companies to increase wages in Vancouver?”
This question was asked recently on the Reddit Vancouver forum. I suspect it is a question which could be asked in many cities across North America and around the world. The question was asked because for many people the cost of housing and the cost of living in general has been rising faster than incomes.
A number of reasons were given in the discussion – maximizing profits for shareholders, a cultural shift towards laziness, in some fields there is a conspiracy to drive down wages by saturating the field with desperate new grads willing to work for peanuts, foreign buyers are driving up the cost of housing, and supply and demand.
Having studied economics this blogger prefers the last one, supply and demand for bodies, but also believes it is a symptom of a much larger problem.
For the most part wages are, with some exceptions, determined by supply and demand. When unemployment rates were low, workers were able to demand and receive a living wage. As there have been more and more unemployed people we are seeing more people not keeping up with the cost of living. Some employers have learned they can do well by paying higher than going wages. But this works because they can attract the best workers and probably would not work for all firms.
The exceptions to the law of supply and demand are those occupations which are protected from competition by government legislation such as licensing requirements. Very often licensing is said to be required to protect standards of service to the public. Doctors must be licensed to ensure we get quality medical care but the licenses also restrict competition and keep doctors incomes high. Teachers are paid well because they have licenses and strong unions in a legal monopoly. People are required to send their children to school and mostly the schools are operated by the state. Government employees also have strong unions and employers that have a monopoly.
The moral of the story is that if you want to have the wages to support a good standard of living, choose an occupation that is legally protected from competition.
Most of us are aware the economy is going through a difficult time but believe it will return to continuous growth. This blogger is an exception. Our economy is in trouble because we have used up the most easily accessible energy and mineral resources. There are lots left but the energy and effort required to extract them make them mostly useless. If this theory is correct, then we are probably faced with a long period of economic stagnation during which the standards of living of a lot of people will go down.
The answer to the question is that it is hard for companies to increase wages in part because wages are determined by supply and demand and in part because the economy is started into a period of decline during which it will be hard for companies to even stay in business.