Health care greed

This post was inspired by a rather long article on why health care in the United States is so expensive.

As I read the first section I was thinking that when it comes to greed some health care people make Wall Street bankers look like amateurs.  By my values the bankers are higher on the ethical ladder than some medical people because the bankers are conning people who are just as greedy.  Medical people are exploiting people when they are sick and at their most vulnerable.

metalmarious_Medicine_and_a_StethoscopeOne of the more interesting university courses I took was sociology of work in which the professor talked about the professional encounter.  We go to a professional when we are in a crisis situation and because the professional has specialized knowledge which can be used to get us out of the crisis.

This gives the professional a great deal of power over us and according to the article it appears some in the he medical profession take full advantage of it.

How do we protect ourselves from medical exploitation?  Normally I would say increase competition.  But one probably doesn’t want to take time to compare prices when having a heart attack.

 

To some extent we can choose a family doctor.  More competition would make this easier.  We might get a little more competition if health people were to be certified by associations rather than licensed by governments in that associations could certify more practitioners and more different types of practitioner.

Maybe the best way to protect ourselves is to live a healthy lifestyle – exercise, eat mostly healthy foods and practice defensive driving.  Even so it is hard to imagine anyone getting through life without interacting with the medical profession.

Criteria for a health care plan

 

With health care likely to become a big issue in the U.S. election and an issue in many other countries here are three points against which I would want included in   a health care plan

First I believe we should have a collective responsibility to ensure all citizens have the opportunity to experience the same standard of living as all other citizens.  That includes health care

The second is that we should be able to make our own lifestyle decisions. Most if not all of us do and eat things which are long-term detrimental to our health and all of us have to take the consequences of those decisions.

The third is that quite a few years ago The Economist reported that 80 per cent of health care spending is in the last six months of life.  This should not be included in our collective responsibility although if a person or family has to resources and wants to go there they should be allowed.

Some years ago there was a story that the Chinese paid their doctors so long as they were healthy.  When they got sick the treatment started and the payments ended. Wouldn’t it be interesting if this concept could be incorporated into a health care plan.

 

If you liked this post your are invited to comment, press the like button and/or click  one of the share buttons. If you disagree you are invited to say why in a comment.  While I like the idea of sharing this platform, my personality is such that I don’t reply to many comments.

The power of professionals

This week’s The Economist has two articles on medicine and doctors in China which prompted the following thoughts.

One of the more fascinating courses I took in university was on the sociology of work where the professor spent some time talking about what makes a professional.

We go to a professional when we are in a crisis and the professional has specialized knowledge which can help us.

This gives professionals a great deal of power over us and it encourages them to let us think they know more than they do.

It also means some of them are able to take advantage of us and it appears this applies to doctors in lots of countries.

The way for us to deal with this is to try to live a reasonable lifestyle (exercise and good diet) and when our turn comes, try to accept it gracefully.

 

If you liked this post your are invited to comment, press the like button and/or click  one of the share buttons. If you disagree you are invited to say why in a comment.  While I like the idea of sharing this platform, my personality is such that I don’t reply to many comments.

%d bloggers like this: